A recent study ranked Hong Kong, Singapore and Tokyo as having the best judicial systems in Asia. Richard Szabo investigates what overseas employment opportunities the Asian markets have to offer.
Lawyers who have contemplated, or even just fantasised about, working overseas may want to have a closer look at Hong Kong, Singapore and Tokyo. A recent poll by Hong Kong consulting firm PERC showed the three cities in question have the best Asian judicial systems, with respect to lawyer education standards, transparency, independence of judicial systems and IP protection.
Despite the financial market meltdown in New York and depressed London market, Hong Kong is showing good prospects. Herbert Smith partner Gareth Thomas says financial services regulatory work has doubled over the past two years, while insurance and employment work has increased by 20%.
There has been a general increase in work involving the energy sector, regulatory matters and project funding. "We are also seeing battles between telcos, since they are operating in one of two sectors that are subject to competition rules. We have seen telco work go up by about eight or 10 fold in the past year," he says.
Thomas adds there has recently been "unprecedented growth" in capital markets, IPOs and M&A, pointing to the firm's work for Goldman Sachs' and Morgan Stanley's HK$13.7bn (A$2.2bn) IPO, SAIF Partners,Hony Capital and IDG Technology Venture Partners' HK$2.7bn (A$437m) acquisition of Digital China Holdings, and BP on its A$2.5bn refinancing of SECCO.
Singapore: competition/tax hot spot
Law firms in Singapore have similarly observed increased work. Since the country's new Competition Act came into force two years ago, many law firms have increased their tax and competition work by as much as 100%.
There have recently been deals ranging from US$200m to US$1bn (A$249m to A$1.2bn) that involved a number of jurisdictions, including Thailand, Malaysia and India. Most M&A lawyers can expect to make at least four international trips a year.
The client base that foreign lawyers deal with would include investment bankers who are more often than not easy to deal with, as they are also expatriates who expect the same level of service they would receive in western countries.
Drew & Napier partner Manoj Sandrasegara says law firms are currently facing a shortage of lawyers in Singapore, since there are too few law graduates to meet demand and some lawyers opt to work overseas. "There is a shortage of lawyers with the skill levels required. We have, however, been fortunate that a number of capable lawyers who have worked in New York and Hong Kong have either joined or returned to us after a stint in those jurisdictions. These lawyers acquired new and improved skill sets while working overseas," he notes.
Tokyo: a shining star
Baker & McKenzie's managing partner Jeremy Pitts in Japan has seen large, complex cross-border deals, in the order of hundreds of millions of US dollars. He says some of this is reflected in financial, corporate and capital markets work, but includes outbound investment from Japanese corporations. "Financial institutions are looking to diversify and invest in utilities, while international power investment is quite hot at the moment," he explains. "Since the commencement of the credit crisis, Japanese financial institutions have been actively investing in US financial institutions and we're likely to see more of this."
Pitts says the firm recently acted for Nomura as the mezzanine lender in the debt financing of Marubeni/TEPCO's (A$287m) bid for Mirant's power assets in the Philippines (A$3.4bn). The firm also acted for Electric Power Development in constructing and operating two gas thermal power generation plants in Thailand (A$2.5bn).
Hays Recruitment director Mark Kadillak says there is a "massive" energy boom in Japan that has made law firms busier than they were in the past decade. "Japanese companies are cash rich and they are in better shape than their US counterparts, and US companies may be attractive targets, so there should be greater M&A activity," says Kadillak.
What employers want Kadillak says during the 23 years he has worked as a recruiter in Japan, he found the most attractive legal talent were those who understood the entertainment industry, music rights and intellectual property law.
Private practice does not require Japanese language skills but rather greater depth of expertise in the given area such as corporate transactions and M&A.
Pitts says he always looks for candidates who have a long-term interest in Japan. "In order to qualify to practise foreign law, you need to be registered and for that you must have three years' experience, of which, in principle, two years must be spent in your home jurisdiction," he states.
Thomas, on the other hand, believes that lawyers who are prepared to do a wider variety of work at a senior level have a better chance of finding work. "You need to be more of a generalist in Hong Kong; we consider ourselves to be doing a wider range of activities than lawyers in Sydney or Auckland might do," he explains.
Hughes-Castell managing director Doreen Jaeger-Soong says Australian lawyers with skills in M&A, private equity, financial services or intellectual property are highest in demand, particularly those who have a good command of business Mandarin or Korean.
"Ideal candidates are those with four to six years' experience with strong Chinese language abilities," she says.
In Singapore, many foreign lawyers join firms as an associate and work their way up to partnership. However, hiring a very senior lawyer or partner requires more than technical skill. He or she must have made a significant contribution to their firm's revenue.
Historically, in Japan, lateral partner recruitment has taken place with candidates from other foreign firms, says Kadillak. Expertise would not be enough for a senior level appointment, since a significant part of a partner's workload is also related to business development, namely clients, contacts and selling the service, he adds. ALB
|
Hong Kong: a convenient city
Known as the second-largest financial centre in Asia, Hong Kong is a busy, compact yet easy city to live in. Most locals speak English and there is a huge variety of stores. Dry cleaning might take longer than in other international cities, but transport is quick.
Most partners or senior associates live in large apartments or houses. However, compared to most properties in Australia or New Zealand, the living space is smaller and rent is more expensive.
|
|
Singapore: easy living
Singapore is located in the heart of the South East Asia, meaning there is plenty of travel opportunity within the region. English is an official language and food is inexpensive; most people to dine out several times each week. About 80% of residents live in high-rise apartments. It is very hot and humid for most of the year, but there is air conditioning in most buildings, glassed walkways and underground tunnels.
However, be warned that owning a car can be expensive. The cheapest cars cost about A$44,000 but most foreign lawyers drive a luxury car priced at A$132,000-175,000.
|
|
Tokyo: Disneyland for adults
Tokyo, or "Disneyland for adults" as some call it, is an easy, centralised, clean, orderly and safe metropolitan city to live in. It is densely populated and busy by day, yet astoundingly peaceful at night.
Most expatriates can find a groundswell of socialising opportunities in Tokyo's Ropongi (night life) district, but as a rule most Japanese refrain from playing loud music at night and stress the importance of cleanliness.
Mercer's worldwide cost of living survey ranked Tokyo as the second most expensive city. The cost of living has mostly fallen over the past 10 years but the notable exception is accommodation.
Despite the prices, most senior lawyers live in relatively large apartments or houses.
|
|
Decent earnings
The highest national tax rate in Japan is about 35%, and when combined with local taxes this amounts to about 45-50%. By comparison, in Singapore the highest rate of income tax is about 20% but can drop to as little as 10%, depending on one's salary. Base salaries are marginally less than what Australian or US firms would pay, but most firms offer bonuses.
In Hong Kong, lawyers can expect to be taxed less than in their home country. The highest tax rate is 16% and work hours are longer, varying between 12-14 hours per day. Some law firm offices are also open on Saturdays.
|
Average annual salaries at foreign firms in Hong Kong
|
Qualification
|
Salary range (A$)
|
|
1 yrs PQE
|
115,490-157,896
|
|
2 yrs PQE
|
125,162-165,598
|
|
3 yrs PQE
|
134,808-179,103
|
|
4 yrs PQE
|
144,438-192,584
|
|
5 yrs PQE
|
156,056-227,340
|
|
6 yrs PQE
|
157,982-250,473
|
|
7 yrs PQE
|
173,405-269,740
|
|
8 yrs PQE
|
192,672-298,522+
|
|
9 yrs PQE
|
260,003+
|
|
10 yrs PQE
|
346,671+
|
Source: Hays Recruitment, 2008
Average annual salaries at foreign firms in Singapore
|
Qualification
|
Salary range (A$)
|
|
1 yrs PQE
|
87,124
|
|
2 yrs PQE
|
95,837
|
|
3 yrs PQE
|
100,225
|
|
4 yrs PQE
|
108,940
|
|
5 yrs PQE
|
113,265
|
|
6 yrs PQE
|
113,265
|
|
7 yrs PQE
|
121,922
|
|
8 yrs PQE
|
130,631
|
|
9 yrs PQE
|
130,631
|
|
10 yrs PQE
|
174,174
|
Source: Hays Recruitment, 2008
Average annual salaries at foreign firms in Japan
|
Qualification
|
Salary range (A$)
|
|
1 yrs PQE
|
91,676-171,892
|
|
2 yrs PQE
|
103,222-183,506
|
|
3 yrs PQE
|
114,813-195,182
|
|
4 yrs PQE
|
137,776-218,135
|
|
5 yrs PQE
|
160,731-229,639
|
|
6 yrs PQE
|
172,229-252,580
|
|
7 yrs PQE
|
183,838-264,268
|
|
8 yrs PQE
|
195,328-275,730
|
|
9 yrs PQE
|
218,286-298,793
|
|
10yrs PQE
|
229,841-344,239+
|
Source: Hays Recruitment, 2008
Cost of living: how does it compare?
|
Rank March 2008
|
Rank March 2007
|
City
|
Country
|
Cost of living Index March 2008
|
Cost of living Index March 2007
|
|
1
|
1
|
Moscow
|
Russia
|
142.4
|
134.4
|
|
2
|
4
|
Tokyo
|
Japan
|
127.0
|
122.1
|
|
3
|
2
|
London
|
UK
|
125.0
|
126.3
|
|
4
|
10
|
Oslo
|
Norway
|
118.3
|
105.8
|
|
5
|
3
|
Seoul
|
South Korea
|
117.7
|
122.4
|
|
6
|
5
|
Hong Kong
|
China
|
117.6
|
119.4
|
|
13
|
14
|
Singapore
|
Singapore
|
109.1
|
100.4
|
|
15
|
21
|
Sydney
|
Australia
|
104.1
|
94.9
|
|
22
|
15
|
New York City
|
US
|
100.0
|
100.0
|
|
78
|
99
|
Auckland
|
New Zealand
|
81
|
73.9
|
Source: Mercer worldwide cost of living survey, 2008